Ashland County Detectives Take Lead in the Mysterious Disappearance of James Beardsley

The search for James Beardsley, 25, who vanished after leaving Columbus, Ohio, on January 5, 2025, continues as law enforcement intensifies efforts across multiple counties. James, described as 6’1”, 200 pounds, with red hair and blue eyes, was last seen in Columbus, Ohio when he left for his home in Polk, Ohio.

 

Detective Aaron Crites of the Ashland County Sheriff’s Office, now leading the case, confirmed that law enforcement agencies, including Richland County, Ashland County, Knox County, Bellville Police Department, and Columbus Police, have been actively involved in the investigation. Search efforts have included aerial drones, cadaver dogs, ground patrols, and a thorough canvassing of the surrounding area.

 

His black 2012 Toyota hatchback was discovered parked behind the Der Dutchman Restaurant in Bellville, Ohio. Detectives believe he arrived there around 1:15pm on January 5, 2025. Inside the vehicle, Detectives found his cell phone along with other items that may assist in the investigation.

 

“We’ve searched the golf course, bike path, and surrounding areas multiple times,” said Detective Crites. “The family has been cooperative, and while items found in his vehicle may provide leads, the case remains an ongoing investigation.”

 

Surveillance footage from the Der Dutchman Restaurant shows James arriving but does not capture him leaving. The motion-activated cameras, impacted by the restaurant’s renovation, offered limited coverage. Law enforcement is in the process of collecting additional video from nearby businesses and highways along State Route 97.

 

“There’s no evidence of foul play or self-harm at this time,” Detective Crites added. “We’ve exhausted many resources and will continue to pursue every possible lead.”

 

Flyers have been distributed throughout Bellville and Columbus, urging residents and businesses to check for any surveillance footage or information regarding James’ disappearance. “Any tips, even seemingly minor, could be helpful,” said Detective Crites.

 

James Beardsley has been listed in a national database for missing persons. Authorities encourage anyone with information about the whereabouts of James Beardsley is urged to contact the Ashland County Sheriff’s Office Detective Bureau at 419-289-8362.